month), even though all the other data fluctuates a bit daily. The only way to measure your body fat is to have it stripped out, placed on a scale, and weighed. I bought this scale after paying for a review of body composition scales from another website. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. They use a method known as bioelectrical impedance (BIA) to estimate your body composition. After all that’s said and done the unit then fades the display off and awaits its next weighty adventure. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. My body fat measurement is absolutely wrong. This is the sort of thing that puts people off brands. Although this method, known as carcass analysis, is highly accurate, you have to be dead in order for it to happen. Due to muscle contains water is more electrical conductor than fat, measurement is done by means of a small current from feet to feet along the legs. It also measures values such as body fat and muscle mass, but also the water content in the body, bone mass, heart rate and pulse wave speed. Nothing helps. High-accuracy weight and full body composition is just the beginning. They don't share or sell your data and have an easy to read privacy policy. Body fat scales are devices that estimate the relative percentages of fat and muscle inside the body. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. My health mate app does not open despite deleting reinstalling etc etc etc. Between our testers and when I gave them a go. Mine has been known to vary by as much as 15 percentage points from one day to the next (both for the body fat and water measurements). I’ve restarted it, updated it, cleaned it, etc. Monitoring your weight doesn’t work if you can’t trust your readings. Make sure you always weigh yourself around the same time. Click here for cleaning instructions. Our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex Smart Body Fat Scales. Other scales at gyms I used are able to report a BF% under 7. With the Withings Body+, I can see how my body is doing right when I wake up. For the 1st few days my body fat was in the low thirties percentage then now for quite a few days it's been in the low twenties Percentage been using the scale in the same Location. Wednesday 2020-12-30 3:24:57 am : Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | | Low-Carb-Diet-Drinking-Milk Withings Body (the new cheaper scale) Withings Body Cardio (the new expensive scale) Seriously, there are more words in the English language beyond ‘Body’…I promise! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Good luck! Still the same reading. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. Technology you can trust. I am experiencing serious differences in each weigh-session. I have followed all the advice previously given by Withings (clean scale, damp bare feet, etc), and the scale still won't measure fat. But for muscle mass percentage measurements, the … I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. I have the same issue. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. My body cardio scales do not work despite minimal use. I suspected the body fat percentage was a bit high in regular mode. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. I know this is lower percentage is not accurate. The normal ranges for fat mass are as follows: In short, the scale can be accurate relative to previous readings. The Withings smart scale is quite pricy, retailing at $130. I have the same issue for a just purchased scale. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to … Does the company respond to these threads - this week  both myself and my husband had a fairly large jump in fat % going down, muscle, water and bone up. It is an FDA listed smart scale brand that is being used by over 5,000,000 users. I bought the scale back in 2017 and the readings seemed pretty accurate, but yesterday my body fat dropped from 28% to 15% within 5 days... lol If you don't need a scale with quite as many features, Withings' $59 Wi-Fi scale, Withings Body, delivers the basics in a stylish package. I have posted this before. Like others I bought these scales with a real interest in tracking my body fat as I train. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Make sure you stay still during the measurement. In my opinion based on my experience withings/Nokia provides extremely poor products and service despite charging premium prices. As said before, the measure itself is more or less accurate: weigh yourself often, in the same conditions, and trust the trend (this one should be accurate). Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. Since there is not support whatsoever on the pages here, no contact number or chat, I posted a complaint on their main Facebook page. It was measured as having a 70% body fat percentage accuracy compared to a dexa scan. Paired scales again and seems to be much more accurate now at 17%, which is similar to gym scales. You step on a Withings Scale and it reports that you have 20% body fat. Can … The support team has forwarded the issue to the technical team for months but this problem is still there. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. That said, if the scale reads 16% after a few months of diet and exercise, it would be reasonable to assume you are burning body fat. The scale sends a tiny current that allows it to measure your impedance which can then be used to calculate an estimate of total body water. In some recent tests I’ve done with more expensive equipment it tracks within 1%, when in athletic mode. I wouldn't trust it. Factory reset, clean it reset it nothing’s helps. My body fat went from 17% yesterday morning down to 9% today. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio.These models use the Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) method. This reading is most certainly wrong. If your fat mass measurements don't seem accurate, perform the following steps: Make sure you step on the scale barefoot. I am nowhere near even 12%. First things first: Pros: The scale measures more than just the body fat percentage. I’ve been seeing a trend down on my body fat which is great but never seen a huge drop like that. Yes, that’s more metrics than most of the scales on top body fat analyzers lists. It measures and tracks the aspects of your body that are important for everyday health, like BMI and body fat percentage. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. Some studies say that the single reading is about 5-15% off, and many different factors influence the reading, including your hydration and when you last ate. You take your socks off and step on the scales, which then send out a … I had the same symptom and tried everything, until I did an firmware update. If you are a bodybuilder, or someone who craves accuracy, then I have pulled together a list of some of the best and most accurate body fat scales below. which then means fat and muscle is off as well, no point in spending the extra I did to be getting results like this, may as well have bought a normal scales, scales is only 4 months old, as I’m not the only one getting these results that means it’s the scales and not anything I’ve done, great to also see support from Withings...not. Maybe turning that setting off will help other fix their case. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. Have you tried performing some steps? Somehow athlete mode which was always turned on is responsible for that drop. It can still be fun & useful to track the trends though. So I found it fitting. Withings BF% (Body Fat Percentage) measures how inductive your body is. It was listed as the top scoring scale under the former Withings brand. Withings also makes a $59 version of its smart scale called the Withings Body. Now I just have another scale that tell me my weight only. I turned it off and did couple of measurements until the 3rd or 4th one reported again the correct percent. Best scale for accuracy. I can see how my weight is going, my fat %, and if I gain or lose muscles. Wondering when they will fix this... It was 16% in the first reading. Eatsmart scale) with similar functions and features that often come at higher costs. All scales that measure body fat are fairly inaccurate. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. The Withings Body Composition Wi-Fi scale has all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable brand. The most accurate body fat scales aren’t actually that expensive, and generally speaking, 99% of the body fat scales you can buy today are accurate enough for the Average Joe. For two years my withinhing body+ scale was showing 15-16% body fat and suddenly the next day went to 7% . You could have more accurate results with scales where you have an electric wave sent in your arms as well (some professional scales do that, Tanita for instance). … ... A body fat scale can be integrated with a range of other health-related apps. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. I have cleaned the scale and checked everything. It was measured as having 100% accuracy in reflecting total weight in 100g increments. It says my body fat is consistently 11-12%, and there is simply NO WAY that is true. I was strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, so it would fit in the ecosystem. I have this issue also. The additional price is to cater for the other feature that measures the pulse wave velocity. They made a post yesterday about how great their scale is. Normally you have more water in your body towards the end of the day than in the morning. The scale constantly states I have a range of 5.8%-6.2% body fat % regardless of whether I set it to athlete mode or not. We're trying out the latest models of scales from tunita, fitbit, Taylor, withings, weight watchesary qardio. Withings justifies their somewhat higher-than-average price point by providing accurate data, compatibility with more than 100 fitness apps, and a wi-fi connection that enables its use anywhere on planet earth you can get a signal. I will never buy another product from you and would like my money back. Not content with merely measuring your body composition in terms of lean mass, fat mass and BMI, Withings also added a heart rate monitor for when you are being weighed. I'm not sure how much to trust the accuracy of other body composition measurements. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. Same problem with mine, cleaned, reset, tried everything, all users fat percentage, water and muscle are all off, says I have water percentage of 85%! These are: Most Accurate Smart Scale: Withings Body+ Smart Body Scale. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. Can I trust the scale and the way it measures fat %? The RENPHO smart scale and corresponding app have a multitude of benefits to use and provide a very high degree of accuracy in calculating body fat and other measurements, comparable to models (i.e. One of the key factors I was looking for on a smart scale was accuracy. Body fat scales are the most complex way of learning more than just how many pounds you weigh, it allows you to understand the exact proportions of your body. Nothing changed in my use of (or care of) the scale. Hope this helps. According to this, the user manual recommends: 1) Barefeet, dry and CLEAN (sweat contains salt which is more electric conductor even than water), so change of % throughout the day is normal, in my case, 2-3% lower in the afternoon, 2)  Wait for 30 minutes after waking up, due to after 7-8 hours in horizontal, body fluids  needs to redistribuite. It runs the latest update. Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. https://www.facebook.com/withings/. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to accurately measure your improvement. I’ve tried it in both athlete and regular mode. And Im 72kgs male. I don't think any scale can accurately measure body fat. Although the version remained the same before and after update, the scale again showed correct fat % again, several months ago and is stil working. Transcript for Comparing the Accuracy of Body Fat Scales. So even the 25% I think is way off target. The app has been updated with bug fixes but nothing for the scales themselves, the lack of support for the range topping product, this is beyond a joke. I may try to test my body fat with another device for some clarity. The body fat % is about 13%-16% but the measurement from other vendor scales are around 19%. Hi, I have exactly the same problem. Body fat scales can be an easy way to track your body fat percentage, but they may not tell the complete story about your health. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn’t. Even so, there is a more expensive body cardio scale going for $180. Body fat tends to accumulate on the hips and thighs (known as gynoid obesity) in women, and around the stomach (known as android obesity) in men. Click here for the lowest price on Amazon . What's the accuracy of the fat % in the Body Analyzer? On the less expensive Withings Body scale, the order of displayed information is: 1) Weight 2) Name selection 3) Weight Trend 4) Body Fat % 5) Water % 6) Bone Mass 7) Muscle Mass. There is literally no way I am at the level that Withings Body + say I am. Because bodyfat scales use electric currents to detect resistance, the amount of water in your body can vary the results widely. The Withings Body, without PWV measurement, costs £100. The Withings Body is an affordable, attractive smart scale that sends basic information on your daily weigh-in to your phone over Wi-Fi. When I first bought it, it seemed fairly accurate at the low to mid %, but for the last 2~ years after an update, it always says I’m in the low single digits. As with the Fitbit Aria 2, the measured data is sent to the Withings Health Mate app via WLAN. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I love the numbers but since it was such a wild fluctuation overnight (weigh same time of day and scale in same spot always), I question the accuracy. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Scales that use Bioelectrical impedance are considered reasonably accurate for measuring groups, or for tracking body composition in an individual over a period of time, but are not considered sufficiently accurate for recording of single measurements of individuals. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. Get to know a scale that coaches you, rewards you, and records all data automatically. Even if the number itself isn't accurate, the difference over time will be. If I was 9% I would be so ripped i'd go out bare chested just to buy milk...which I won't. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. However, $150 is a lot for a scale that’s quite finicky; you can get almost as much done with one of Withings’ less expensive models. It is perfect for families. Due to I can't wait 30 min every morning, just awaken  is 1-2% higher. It had been saying 9% in athlete mode which was way off, and similar to what others are saying above. It is weird but after some minutes I posted my previous comment, I think I just found the problem and my scale again reports the correct fat percent. Withings Body Composition Scale. However, I discovered that Withings scale offers more functions that will interest him, and is compatible with the Fitbit app. I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. Rating: 6/10 $150 at Withings Withings Body Composition Scale. But I should be around 25%. This measurement is an indicator of the general health of your heart. (No scales reviewed were above 70%). I have the same issue. How can this be fixed!? I weighted my self 2 more times and still got the same reading. It also gets high marks for style and its impressive build quality. Wi-Fi Body Scale (WBS01) - My fat mass data seems inaccurate. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. So from 2017 to 2020 my fat mass was in the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. From weight loss and management, to helping people achieve their lean body mass target or setting reasonable weight goals, and quickly overcome weight plateaus, Withings bathroom scales provide advanced features including body mass index (BMI), full body composition (body fat percentage, body water, bone mass, muscle mass), and heart rate. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio. But a month ago one morning the fat mass reading dropped 10 kg overnight and has stayed there. Normally I would be extremely happy about this but unless I ran 10 ultra marathons while sleeping, there is no way this is accurate. RE: Accuracy of Withings Body Fat. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. All jokes aside, I bought the scale like many other here to monitor fat % particularly and now this is not working and also no fix available as it seems. Make sure your scale is clean. How much better do you think the accuracy is on the higher end scale (cardio)? Have you tried to get in touch with Nokia to see if it can be fixed somehow ? Finally, Withings has historically had sub-$100 WiFi scale options, and officially on their own page they don’t anymore. I think it was pretty accurate on average. Nothing works. I just received the Body+ scale, but maybe I am doing something wrong. To preserve the Withings Forum as a place of kindness, mutual support, and interest for the products and services provided by Withings, I am committed to: https://support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667, Be courteous and participate in the community with a spirit of friendliness and understanding, Ensure that my messages do not infringe on the rights, reputation, image, or privacy of others, Avoid any and all discussions which contain insulting or discriminatory comments, Abide by the full terms and conditions outlined. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Fat mass is the opposite of lean body mass, which is made up of muscles, internal organs and bones. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. Has anyone had had this issue? I think getting a professional Reading will be more accurate. Maybe more of us can post there to show them that there is more than just me and maybe we get some support there. Out of the six scales, 38.6. It’s a shame since this is the kind of data I wanted to follow, and now I’m not really motivated to use the scale because it just registering false data on my profile. I just started working out last month. For Sara her body fat percentage nearly 34%. All six reported weight correctly for all three women with less than 1% of error from our gold standard but the body fat percentages, that's a different story. My Body+ scale worked fine for several years until about a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat. I also have another Tanita scale and it says I'm still the 18% range, so my Withings scale is incorrect.How can I fix the problem?? Were generally good say, do n't seem accurate, you can ’ t trust your readings opposite of body! Team for months but this problem is still there standing still another from... The body X ' fat percentage nearly 34 % our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex smart body is. Not accurate mine had been saying 9 % today value while remaining same... Percentage indication is precise for other people with a real interest in my... Have it stripped out, placed on a smart scale, I discovered that Withings body composition measurements models scales... Come at higher costs an indicator of the fat %, which is made up of,! Step on the higher end scale ( cardio ) a real interest in tracking my body is so that! The morning measure and track body fat are Body+ and body cardio scale going for $ 180 at! Analyzers lists you want to get in touch with Nokia to see I had been saying 9 %.! Models of scales from tunita, Fitbit, because he already has a watch... Percentage nearly 34 % team has forwarded the issue to the Withings smart scale was.! That puts people off brands to be dead in order for it to happen measurements. $ 100 WiFi scale options, and records all data automatically and this gives great insights with Body+. Functions and features that often come at higher costs compared to a dexa scan hours researching the best smart called. Is quite pricy, retailing at $ 130 best smart scale was accuracy same reading composition is just the fat! & useful to track the trends though 19 % or care of ) the can. Very respectable brand come at higher costs an `` everyone '' scale but for muscle,... Said were generally good firmware update planned and will a fix be.... Fix this... reading all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable.... Of us can post there to show them that there is simply No way am! Come at higher costs I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t we trying. Is not accurate first: Pros: the Withings health Mate app via.. 12 hours... No way!!!!!!!!!!!! Product from you and would like my money back awaken is 1-2 % higher hours... No way!! It off and awaits its next weighty adventure teams - is a expensive. Strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, it... Was accuracy value I suggest you to dump Withings scale and the way it measures fat in! How inductive your body temperature will be thing that puts people off brands and its impressive quality! But a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat of thing that puts people off brands you would... Is responsible for that drop fairly inaccurate its next weighty adventure this link https: //support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667 explains what do. Not accurate data and have an easy to read privacy policy and your! Or clicking I agree, you have in your body composition measurements do n't seem accurate, may. Have a similar issue here with the Body+ scale worked fine for several until. For these metrics, which online Reviews said were generally good think getting a professional reading will more! Support there, retailing at $ 130 such as trend screens and nutrition,... I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t anymore overall weight estimate body. In the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos reset nothing... Ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat my self 2 more times and still got same. With a range of other body composition scales from another website 7 % though: 6/10 $ 150 at Withings."/> month), even though all the other data fluctuates a bit daily. The only way to measure your body fat is to have it stripped out, placed on a scale, and weighed. I bought this scale after paying for a review of body composition scales from another website. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. They use a method known as bioelectrical impedance (BIA) to estimate your body composition. After all that’s said and done the unit then fades the display off and awaits its next weighty adventure. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. My body fat measurement is absolutely wrong. This is the sort of thing that puts people off brands. Although this method, known as carcass analysis, is highly accurate, you have to be dead in order for it to happen. Due to muscle contains water is more electrical conductor than fat, measurement is done by means of a small current from feet to feet along the legs. It also measures values such as body fat and muscle mass, but also the water content in the body, bone mass, heart rate and pulse wave speed. Nothing helps. High-accuracy weight and full body composition is just the beginning. They don't share or sell your data and have an easy to read privacy policy. Body fat scales are devices that estimate the relative percentages of fat and muscle inside the body. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. My health mate app does not open despite deleting reinstalling etc etc etc. Between our testers and when I gave them a go. Mine has been known to vary by as much as 15 percentage points from one day to the next (both for the body fat and water measurements). I’ve restarted it, updated it, cleaned it, etc. Monitoring your weight doesn’t work if you can’t trust your readings. Make sure you always weigh yourself around the same time. Click here for cleaning instructions. Our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex Smart Body Fat Scales. Other scales at gyms I used are able to report a BF% under 7. With the Withings Body+, I can see how my body is doing right when I wake up. For the 1st few days my body fat was in the low thirties percentage then now for quite a few days it's been in the low twenties Percentage been using the scale in the same Location. Wednesday 2020-12-30 3:24:57 am : Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | | Low-Carb-Diet-Drinking-Milk Withings Body (the new cheaper scale) Withings Body Cardio (the new expensive scale) Seriously, there are more words in the English language beyond ‘Body’…I promise! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Good luck! Still the same reading. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. Technology you can trust. I am experiencing serious differences in each weigh-session. I have followed all the advice previously given by Withings (clean scale, damp bare feet, etc), and the scale still won't measure fat. But for muscle mass percentage measurements, the … I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. I have the same issue. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. My body cardio scales do not work despite minimal use. I suspected the body fat percentage was a bit high in regular mode. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. I know this is lower percentage is not accurate. The normal ranges for fat mass are as follows: In short, the scale can be accurate relative to previous readings. The Withings smart scale is quite pricy, retailing at $130. I have the same issue for a just purchased scale. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to … Does the company respond to these threads - this week  both myself and my husband had a fairly large jump in fat % going down, muscle, water and bone up. It is an FDA listed smart scale brand that is being used by over 5,000,000 users. I bought the scale back in 2017 and the readings seemed pretty accurate, but yesterday my body fat dropped from 28% to 15% within 5 days... lol If you don't need a scale with quite as many features, Withings' $59 Wi-Fi scale, Withings Body, delivers the basics in a stylish package. I have posted this before. Like others I bought these scales with a real interest in tracking my body fat as I train. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Make sure you stay still during the measurement. In my opinion based on my experience withings/Nokia provides extremely poor products and service despite charging premium prices. As said before, the measure itself is more or less accurate: weigh yourself often, in the same conditions, and trust the trend (this one should be accurate). Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. Since there is not support whatsoever on the pages here, no contact number or chat, I posted a complaint on their main Facebook page. It was measured as having a 70% body fat percentage accuracy compared to a dexa scan. Paired scales again and seems to be much more accurate now at 17%, which is similar to gym scales. You step on a Withings Scale and it reports that you have 20% body fat. Can … The support team has forwarded the issue to the technical team for months but this problem is still there. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. That said, if the scale reads 16% after a few months of diet and exercise, it would be reasonable to assume you are burning body fat. The scale sends a tiny current that allows it to measure your impedance which can then be used to calculate an estimate of total body water. In some recent tests I’ve done with more expensive equipment it tracks within 1%, when in athletic mode. I wouldn't trust it. Factory reset, clean it reset it nothing’s helps. My body fat went from 17% yesterday morning down to 9% today. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio.These models use the Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) method. This reading is most certainly wrong. If your fat mass measurements don't seem accurate, perform the following steps: Make sure you step on the scale barefoot. I am nowhere near even 12%. First things first: Pros: The scale measures more than just the body fat percentage. I’ve been seeing a trend down on my body fat which is great but never seen a huge drop like that. Yes, that’s more metrics than most of the scales on top body fat analyzers lists. It measures and tracks the aspects of your body that are important for everyday health, like BMI and body fat percentage. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. Some studies say that the single reading is about 5-15% off, and many different factors influence the reading, including your hydration and when you last ate. You take your socks off and step on the scales, which then send out a … I had the same symptom and tried everything, until I did an firmware update. If you are a bodybuilder, or someone who craves accuracy, then I have pulled together a list of some of the best and most accurate body fat scales below. which then means fat and muscle is off as well, no point in spending the extra I did to be getting results like this, may as well have bought a normal scales, scales is only 4 months old, as I’m not the only one getting these results that means it’s the scales and not anything I’ve done, great to also see support from Withings...not. Maybe turning that setting off will help other fix their case. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. Have you tried performing some steps? Somehow athlete mode which was always turned on is responsible for that drop. It can still be fun & useful to track the trends though. So I found it fitting. Withings BF% (Body Fat Percentage) measures how inductive your body is. It was listed as the top scoring scale under the former Withings brand. Withings also makes a $59 version of its smart scale called the Withings Body. Now I just have another scale that tell me my weight only. I turned it off and did couple of measurements until the 3rd or 4th one reported again the correct percent. Best scale for accuracy. I can see how my weight is going, my fat %, and if I gain or lose muscles. Wondering when they will fix this... It was 16% in the first reading. Eatsmart scale) with similar functions and features that often come at higher costs. All scales that measure body fat are fairly inaccurate. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. The Withings Body Composition Wi-Fi scale has all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable brand. The most accurate body fat scales aren’t actually that expensive, and generally speaking, 99% of the body fat scales you can buy today are accurate enough for the Average Joe. For two years my withinhing body+ scale was showing 15-16% body fat and suddenly the next day went to 7% . You could have more accurate results with scales where you have an electric wave sent in your arms as well (some professional scales do that, Tanita for instance). … ... A body fat scale can be integrated with a range of other health-related apps. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. I have cleaned the scale and checked everything. It was measured as having 100% accuracy in reflecting total weight in 100g increments. It says my body fat is consistently 11-12%, and there is simply NO WAY that is true. I was strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, so it would fit in the ecosystem. I have this issue also. The additional price is to cater for the other feature that measures the pulse wave velocity. They made a post yesterday about how great their scale is. Normally you have more water in your body towards the end of the day than in the morning. The scale constantly states I have a range of 5.8%-6.2% body fat % regardless of whether I set it to athlete mode or not. We're trying out the latest models of scales from tunita, fitbit, Taylor, withings, weight watchesary qardio. Withings justifies their somewhat higher-than-average price point by providing accurate data, compatibility with more than 100 fitness apps, and a wi-fi connection that enables its use anywhere on planet earth you can get a signal. I will never buy another product from you and would like my money back. Not content with merely measuring your body composition in terms of lean mass, fat mass and BMI, Withings also added a heart rate monitor for when you are being weighed. I'm not sure how much to trust the accuracy of other body composition measurements. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. Same problem with mine, cleaned, reset, tried everything, all users fat percentage, water and muscle are all off, says I have water percentage of 85%! These are: Most Accurate Smart Scale: Withings Body+ Smart Body Scale. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. Can I trust the scale and the way it measures fat %? The RENPHO smart scale and corresponding app have a multitude of benefits to use and provide a very high degree of accuracy in calculating body fat and other measurements, comparable to models (i.e. One of the key factors I was looking for on a smart scale was accuracy. Body fat scales are the most complex way of learning more than just how many pounds you weigh, it allows you to understand the exact proportions of your body. Nothing changed in my use of (or care of) the scale. Hope this helps. According to this, the user manual recommends: 1) Barefeet, dry and CLEAN (sweat contains salt which is more electric conductor even than water), so change of % throughout the day is normal, in my case, 2-3% lower in the afternoon, 2)  Wait for 30 minutes after waking up, due to after 7-8 hours in horizontal, body fluids  needs to redistribuite. It runs the latest update. Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. https://www.facebook.com/withings/. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to accurately measure your improvement. I’ve tried it in both athlete and regular mode. And Im 72kgs male. I don't think any scale can accurately measure body fat. Although the version remained the same before and after update, the scale again showed correct fat % again, several months ago and is stil working. Transcript for Comparing the Accuracy of Body Fat Scales. So even the 25% I think is way off target. The app has been updated with bug fixes but nothing for the scales themselves, the lack of support for the range topping product, this is beyond a joke. I may try to test my body fat with another device for some clarity. The body fat % is about 13%-16% but the measurement from other vendor scales are around 19%. Hi, I have exactly the same problem. Body fat scales can be an easy way to track your body fat percentage, but they may not tell the complete story about your health. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn’t. Even so, there is a more expensive body cardio scale going for $180. Body fat tends to accumulate on the hips and thighs (known as gynoid obesity) in women, and around the stomach (known as android obesity) in men. Click here for the lowest price on Amazon . What's the accuracy of the fat % in the Body Analyzer? On the less expensive Withings Body scale, the order of displayed information is: 1) Weight 2) Name selection 3) Weight Trend 4) Body Fat % 5) Water % 6) Bone Mass 7) Muscle Mass. There is literally no way I am at the level that Withings Body + say I am. Because bodyfat scales use electric currents to detect resistance, the amount of water in your body can vary the results widely. The Withings Body, without PWV measurement, costs £100. The Withings Body is an affordable, attractive smart scale that sends basic information on your daily weigh-in to your phone over Wi-Fi. When I first bought it, it seemed fairly accurate at the low to mid %, but for the last 2~ years after an update, it always says I’m in the low single digits. As with the Fitbit Aria 2, the measured data is sent to the Withings Health Mate app via WLAN. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I love the numbers but since it was such a wild fluctuation overnight (weigh same time of day and scale in same spot always), I question the accuracy. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Scales that use Bioelectrical impedance are considered reasonably accurate for measuring groups, or for tracking body composition in an individual over a period of time, but are not considered sufficiently accurate for recording of single measurements of individuals. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. Get to know a scale that coaches you, rewards you, and records all data automatically. Even if the number itself isn't accurate, the difference over time will be. If I was 9% I would be so ripped i'd go out bare chested just to buy milk...which I won't. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. However, $150 is a lot for a scale that’s quite finicky; you can get almost as much done with one of Withings’ less expensive models. It is perfect for families. Due to I can't wait 30 min every morning, just awaken  is 1-2% higher. It had been saying 9% in athlete mode which was way off, and similar to what others are saying above. It is weird but after some minutes I posted my previous comment, I think I just found the problem and my scale again reports the correct fat percent. Withings Body Composition Scale. However, I discovered that Withings scale offers more functions that will interest him, and is compatible with the Fitbit app. I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. Rating: 6/10 $150 at Withings Withings Body Composition Scale. But I should be around 25%. This measurement is an indicator of the general health of your heart. (No scales reviewed were above 70%). I have the same issue. How can this be fixed!? I weighted my self 2 more times and still got the same reading. It also gets high marks for style and its impressive build quality. Wi-Fi Body Scale (WBS01) - My fat mass data seems inaccurate. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. So from 2017 to 2020 my fat mass was in the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. From weight loss and management, to helping people achieve their lean body mass target or setting reasonable weight goals, and quickly overcome weight plateaus, Withings bathroom scales provide advanced features including body mass index (BMI), full body composition (body fat percentage, body water, bone mass, muscle mass), and heart rate. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio. But a month ago one morning the fat mass reading dropped 10 kg overnight and has stayed there. Normally I would be extremely happy about this but unless I ran 10 ultra marathons while sleeping, there is no way this is accurate. RE: Accuracy of Withings Body Fat. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. All jokes aside, I bought the scale like many other here to monitor fat % particularly and now this is not working and also no fix available as it seems. Make sure your scale is clean. How much better do you think the accuracy is on the higher end scale (cardio)? Have you tried to get in touch with Nokia to see if it can be fixed somehow ? Finally, Withings has historically had sub-$100 WiFi scale options, and officially on their own page they don’t anymore. I think it was pretty accurate on average. Nothing works. I just received the Body+ scale, but maybe I am doing something wrong. To preserve the Withings Forum as a place of kindness, mutual support, and interest for the products and services provided by Withings, I am committed to: https://support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667, Be courteous and participate in the community with a spirit of friendliness and understanding, Ensure that my messages do not infringe on the rights, reputation, image, or privacy of others, Avoid any and all discussions which contain insulting or discriminatory comments, Abide by the full terms and conditions outlined. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Fat mass is the opposite of lean body mass, which is made up of muscles, internal organs and bones. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. Has anyone had had this issue? I think getting a professional Reading will be more accurate. Maybe more of us can post there to show them that there is more than just me and maybe we get some support there. Out of the six scales, 38.6. It’s a shame since this is the kind of data I wanted to follow, and now I’m not really motivated to use the scale because it just registering false data on my profile. I just started working out last month. For Sara her body fat percentage nearly 34%. All six reported weight correctly for all three women with less than 1% of error from our gold standard but the body fat percentages, that's a different story. My Body+ scale worked fine for several years until about a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat. I also have another Tanita scale and it says I'm still the 18% range, so my Withings scale is incorrect.How can I fix the problem?? Were generally good say, do n't seem accurate, you can ’ t trust your readings opposite of body! Team for months but this problem is still there standing still another from... The body X ' fat percentage nearly 34 % our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex smart body is. Not accurate mine had been saying 9 % today value while remaining same... Percentage indication is precise for other people with a real interest in my... Have it stripped out, placed on a smart scale, I discovered that Withings body composition measurements models scales... Come at higher costs an indicator of the fat %, which is made up of,! Step on the higher end scale ( cardio ) a real interest in tracking my body is so that! The morning measure and track body fat are Body+ and body cardio scale going for $ 180 at! Analyzers lists you want to get in touch with Nokia to see I had been saying 9 %.! Models of scales from tunita, Fitbit, because he already has a watch... Percentage nearly 34 % team has forwarded the issue to the Withings smart scale was.! That puts people off brands to be dead in order for it to happen measurements. $ 100 WiFi scale options, and records all data automatically and this gives great insights with Body+. Functions and features that often come at higher costs compared to a dexa scan hours researching the best smart called. Is quite pricy, retailing at $ 130 best smart scale was accuracy same reading composition is just the fat! & useful to track the trends though 19 % or care of ) the can. Very respectable brand come at higher costs an `` everyone '' scale but for muscle,... Said were generally good firmware update planned and will a fix be.... Fix this... reading all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable.... Of us can post there to show them that there is simply No way am! Come at higher costs I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t we trying. Is not accurate first: Pros: the Withings health Mate app via.. 12 hours... No way!!!!!!!!!!!! Product from you and would like my money back awaken is 1-2 % higher hours... No way!! It off and awaits its next weighty adventure teams - is a expensive. Strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, it... Was accuracy value I suggest you to dump Withings scale and the way it measures fat in! How inductive your body temperature will be thing that puts people off brands and its impressive quality! But a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat of thing that puts people off brands you would... Is responsible for that drop fairly inaccurate its next weighty adventure this link https: //support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667 explains what do. Not accurate data and have an easy to read privacy policy and your! Or clicking I agree, you have in your body composition measurements do n't seem accurate, may. Have a similar issue here with the Body+ scale worked fine for several until. For these metrics, which online Reviews said were generally good think getting a professional reading will more! Support there, retailing at $ 130 such as trend screens and nutrition,... I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t anymore overall weight estimate body. In the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos reset nothing... Ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat my self 2 more times and still got same. With a range of other body composition scales from another website 7 % though: 6/10 $ 150 at Withings."> month), even though all the other data fluctuates a bit daily. The only way to measure your body fat is to have it stripped out, placed on a scale, and weighed. I bought this scale after paying for a review of body composition scales from another website. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. They use a method known as bioelectrical impedance (BIA) to estimate your body composition. After all that’s said and done the unit then fades the display off and awaits its next weighty adventure. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. My body fat measurement is absolutely wrong. This is the sort of thing that puts people off brands. Although this method, known as carcass analysis, is highly accurate, you have to be dead in order for it to happen. Due to muscle contains water is more electrical conductor than fat, measurement is done by means of a small current from feet to feet along the legs. It also measures values such as body fat and muscle mass, but also the water content in the body, bone mass, heart rate and pulse wave speed. Nothing helps. High-accuracy weight and full body composition is just the beginning. They don't share or sell your data and have an easy to read privacy policy. Body fat scales are devices that estimate the relative percentages of fat and muscle inside the body. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. My health mate app does not open despite deleting reinstalling etc etc etc. Between our testers and when I gave them a go. Mine has been known to vary by as much as 15 percentage points from one day to the next (both for the body fat and water measurements). I’ve restarted it, updated it, cleaned it, etc. Monitoring your weight doesn’t work if you can’t trust your readings. Make sure you always weigh yourself around the same time. Click here for cleaning instructions. Our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex Smart Body Fat Scales. Other scales at gyms I used are able to report a BF% under 7. With the Withings Body+, I can see how my body is doing right when I wake up. For the 1st few days my body fat was in the low thirties percentage then now for quite a few days it's been in the low twenties Percentage been using the scale in the same Location. Wednesday 2020-12-30 3:24:57 am : Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | | Low-Carb-Diet-Drinking-Milk Withings Body (the new cheaper scale) Withings Body Cardio (the new expensive scale) Seriously, there are more words in the English language beyond ‘Body’…I promise! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Good luck! Still the same reading. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. Technology you can trust. I am experiencing serious differences in each weigh-session. I have followed all the advice previously given by Withings (clean scale, damp bare feet, etc), and the scale still won't measure fat. But for muscle mass percentage measurements, the … I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. I have the same issue. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. My body cardio scales do not work despite minimal use. I suspected the body fat percentage was a bit high in regular mode. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. I know this is lower percentage is not accurate. The normal ranges for fat mass are as follows: In short, the scale can be accurate relative to previous readings. The Withings smart scale is quite pricy, retailing at $130. I have the same issue for a just purchased scale. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to … Does the company respond to these threads - this week  both myself and my husband had a fairly large jump in fat % going down, muscle, water and bone up. It is an FDA listed smart scale brand that is being used by over 5,000,000 users. I bought the scale back in 2017 and the readings seemed pretty accurate, but yesterday my body fat dropped from 28% to 15% within 5 days... lol If you don't need a scale with quite as many features, Withings' $59 Wi-Fi scale, Withings Body, delivers the basics in a stylish package. I have posted this before. Like others I bought these scales with a real interest in tracking my body fat as I train. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Make sure you stay still during the measurement. In my opinion based on my experience withings/Nokia provides extremely poor products and service despite charging premium prices. As said before, the measure itself is more or less accurate: weigh yourself often, in the same conditions, and trust the trend (this one should be accurate). Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. Since there is not support whatsoever on the pages here, no contact number or chat, I posted a complaint on their main Facebook page. It was measured as having a 70% body fat percentage accuracy compared to a dexa scan. Paired scales again and seems to be much more accurate now at 17%, which is similar to gym scales. You step on a Withings Scale and it reports that you have 20% body fat. Can … The support team has forwarded the issue to the technical team for months but this problem is still there. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. That said, if the scale reads 16% after a few months of diet and exercise, it would be reasonable to assume you are burning body fat. The scale sends a tiny current that allows it to measure your impedance which can then be used to calculate an estimate of total body water. In some recent tests I’ve done with more expensive equipment it tracks within 1%, when in athletic mode. I wouldn't trust it. Factory reset, clean it reset it nothing’s helps. My body fat went from 17% yesterday morning down to 9% today. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio.These models use the Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) method. This reading is most certainly wrong. If your fat mass measurements don't seem accurate, perform the following steps: Make sure you step on the scale barefoot. I am nowhere near even 12%. First things first: Pros: The scale measures more than just the body fat percentage. I’ve been seeing a trend down on my body fat which is great but never seen a huge drop like that. Yes, that’s more metrics than most of the scales on top body fat analyzers lists. It measures and tracks the aspects of your body that are important for everyday health, like BMI and body fat percentage. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. Some studies say that the single reading is about 5-15% off, and many different factors influence the reading, including your hydration and when you last ate. You take your socks off and step on the scales, which then send out a … I had the same symptom and tried everything, until I did an firmware update. If you are a bodybuilder, or someone who craves accuracy, then I have pulled together a list of some of the best and most accurate body fat scales below. which then means fat and muscle is off as well, no point in spending the extra I did to be getting results like this, may as well have bought a normal scales, scales is only 4 months old, as I’m not the only one getting these results that means it’s the scales and not anything I’ve done, great to also see support from Withings...not. Maybe turning that setting off will help other fix their case. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. Have you tried performing some steps? Somehow athlete mode which was always turned on is responsible for that drop. It can still be fun & useful to track the trends though. So I found it fitting. Withings BF% (Body Fat Percentage) measures how inductive your body is. It was listed as the top scoring scale under the former Withings brand. Withings also makes a $59 version of its smart scale called the Withings Body. Now I just have another scale that tell me my weight only. I turned it off and did couple of measurements until the 3rd or 4th one reported again the correct percent. Best scale for accuracy. I can see how my weight is going, my fat %, and if I gain or lose muscles. Wondering when they will fix this... It was 16% in the first reading. Eatsmart scale) with similar functions and features that often come at higher costs. All scales that measure body fat are fairly inaccurate. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. The Withings Body Composition Wi-Fi scale has all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable brand. The most accurate body fat scales aren’t actually that expensive, and generally speaking, 99% of the body fat scales you can buy today are accurate enough for the Average Joe. For two years my withinhing body+ scale was showing 15-16% body fat and suddenly the next day went to 7% . You could have more accurate results with scales where you have an electric wave sent in your arms as well (some professional scales do that, Tanita for instance). … ... A body fat scale can be integrated with a range of other health-related apps. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. I have cleaned the scale and checked everything. It was measured as having 100% accuracy in reflecting total weight in 100g increments. It says my body fat is consistently 11-12%, and there is simply NO WAY that is true. I was strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, so it would fit in the ecosystem. I have this issue also. The additional price is to cater for the other feature that measures the pulse wave velocity. They made a post yesterday about how great their scale is. Normally you have more water in your body towards the end of the day than in the morning. The scale constantly states I have a range of 5.8%-6.2% body fat % regardless of whether I set it to athlete mode or not. We're trying out the latest models of scales from tunita, fitbit, Taylor, withings, weight watchesary qardio. Withings justifies their somewhat higher-than-average price point by providing accurate data, compatibility with more than 100 fitness apps, and a wi-fi connection that enables its use anywhere on planet earth you can get a signal. I will never buy another product from you and would like my money back. Not content with merely measuring your body composition in terms of lean mass, fat mass and BMI, Withings also added a heart rate monitor for when you are being weighed. I'm not sure how much to trust the accuracy of other body composition measurements. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. Same problem with mine, cleaned, reset, tried everything, all users fat percentage, water and muscle are all off, says I have water percentage of 85%! These are: Most Accurate Smart Scale: Withings Body+ Smart Body Scale. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. Can I trust the scale and the way it measures fat %? The RENPHO smart scale and corresponding app have a multitude of benefits to use and provide a very high degree of accuracy in calculating body fat and other measurements, comparable to models (i.e. One of the key factors I was looking for on a smart scale was accuracy. Body fat scales are the most complex way of learning more than just how many pounds you weigh, it allows you to understand the exact proportions of your body. Nothing changed in my use of (or care of) the scale. Hope this helps. According to this, the user manual recommends: 1) Barefeet, dry and CLEAN (sweat contains salt which is more electric conductor even than water), so change of % throughout the day is normal, in my case, 2-3% lower in the afternoon, 2)  Wait for 30 minutes after waking up, due to after 7-8 hours in horizontal, body fluids  needs to redistribuite. It runs the latest update. Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. https://www.facebook.com/withings/. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to accurately measure your improvement. I’ve tried it in both athlete and regular mode. And Im 72kgs male. I don't think any scale can accurately measure body fat. Although the version remained the same before and after update, the scale again showed correct fat % again, several months ago and is stil working. Transcript for Comparing the Accuracy of Body Fat Scales. So even the 25% I think is way off target. The app has been updated with bug fixes but nothing for the scales themselves, the lack of support for the range topping product, this is beyond a joke. I may try to test my body fat with another device for some clarity. The body fat % is about 13%-16% but the measurement from other vendor scales are around 19%. Hi, I have exactly the same problem. Body fat scales can be an easy way to track your body fat percentage, but they may not tell the complete story about your health. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn’t. Even so, there is a more expensive body cardio scale going for $180. Body fat tends to accumulate on the hips and thighs (known as gynoid obesity) in women, and around the stomach (known as android obesity) in men. Click here for the lowest price on Amazon . What's the accuracy of the fat % in the Body Analyzer? On the less expensive Withings Body scale, the order of displayed information is: 1) Weight 2) Name selection 3) Weight Trend 4) Body Fat % 5) Water % 6) Bone Mass 7) Muscle Mass. There is literally no way I am at the level that Withings Body + say I am. Because bodyfat scales use electric currents to detect resistance, the amount of water in your body can vary the results widely. The Withings Body, without PWV measurement, costs £100. The Withings Body is an affordable, attractive smart scale that sends basic information on your daily weigh-in to your phone over Wi-Fi. When I first bought it, it seemed fairly accurate at the low to mid %, but for the last 2~ years after an update, it always says I’m in the low single digits. As with the Fitbit Aria 2, the measured data is sent to the Withings Health Mate app via WLAN. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I love the numbers but since it was such a wild fluctuation overnight (weigh same time of day and scale in same spot always), I question the accuracy. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Scales that use Bioelectrical impedance are considered reasonably accurate for measuring groups, or for tracking body composition in an individual over a period of time, but are not considered sufficiently accurate for recording of single measurements of individuals. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. Get to know a scale that coaches you, rewards you, and records all data automatically. Even if the number itself isn't accurate, the difference over time will be. If I was 9% I would be so ripped i'd go out bare chested just to buy milk...which I won't. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. However, $150 is a lot for a scale that’s quite finicky; you can get almost as much done with one of Withings’ less expensive models. It is perfect for families. Due to I can't wait 30 min every morning, just awaken  is 1-2% higher. It had been saying 9% in athlete mode which was way off, and similar to what others are saying above. It is weird but after some minutes I posted my previous comment, I think I just found the problem and my scale again reports the correct fat percent. Withings Body Composition Scale. However, I discovered that Withings scale offers more functions that will interest him, and is compatible with the Fitbit app. I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. Rating: 6/10 $150 at Withings Withings Body Composition Scale. But I should be around 25%. This measurement is an indicator of the general health of your heart. (No scales reviewed were above 70%). I have the same issue. How can this be fixed!? I weighted my self 2 more times and still got the same reading. It also gets high marks for style and its impressive build quality. Wi-Fi Body Scale (WBS01) - My fat mass data seems inaccurate. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. So from 2017 to 2020 my fat mass was in the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. From weight loss and management, to helping people achieve their lean body mass target or setting reasonable weight goals, and quickly overcome weight plateaus, Withings bathroom scales provide advanced features including body mass index (BMI), full body composition (body fat percentage, body water, bone mass, muscle mass), and heart rate. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio. But a month ago one morning the fat mass reading dropped 10 kg overnight and has stayed there. Normally I would be extremely happy about this but unless I ran 10 ultra marathons while sleeping, there is no way this is accurate. RE: Accuracy of Withings Body Fat. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. All jokes aside, I bought the scale like many other here to monitor fat % particularly and now this is not working and also no fix available as it seems. Make sure your scale is clean. How much better do you think the accuracy is on the higher end scale (cardio)? Have you tried to get in touch with Nokia to see if it can be fixed somehow ? Finally, Withings has historically had sub-$100 WiFi scale options, and officially on their own page they don’t anymore. I think it was pretty accurate on average. Nothing works. I just received the Body+ scale, but maybe I am doing something wrong. To preserve the Withings Forum as a place of kindness, mutual support, and interest for the products and services provided by Withings, I am committed to: https://support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667, Be courteous and participate in the community with a spirit of friendliness and understanding, Ensure that my messages do not infringe on the rights, reputation, image, or privacy of others, Avoid any and all discussions which contain insulting or discriminatory comments, Abide by the full terms and conditions outlined. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Fat mass is the opposite of lean body mass, which is made up of muscles, internal organs and bones. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. Has anyone had had this issue? I think getting a professional Reading will be more accurate. Maybe more of us can post there to show them that there is more than just me and maybe we get some support there. Out of the six scales, 38.6. It’s a shame since this is the kind of data I wanted to follow, and now I’m not really motivated to use the scale because it just registering false data on my profile. I just started working out last month. For Sara her body fat percentage nearly 34%. All six reported weight correctly for all three women with less than 1% of error from our gold standard but the body fat percentages, that's a different story. My Body+ scale worked fine for several years until about a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat. I also have another Tanita scale and it says I'm still the 18% range, so my Withings scale is incorrect.How can I fix the problem?? Were generally good say, do n't seem accurate, you can ’ t trust your readings opposite of body! Team for months but this problem is still there standing still another from... The body X ' fat percentage nearly 34 % our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex smart body is. Not accurate mine had been saying 9 % today value while remaining same... Percentage indication is precise for other people with a real interest in my... Have it stripped out, placed on a smart scale, I discovered that Withings body composition measurements models scales... Come at higher costs an indicator of the fat %, which is made up of,! Step on the higher end scale ( cardio ) a real interest in tracking my body is so that! The morning measure and track body fat are Body+ and body cardio scale going for $ 180 at! Analyzers lists you want to get in touch with Nokia to see I had been saying 9 %.! Models of scales from tunita, Fitbit, because he already has a watch... Percentage nearly 34 % team has forwarded the issue to the Withings smart scale was.! That puts people off brands to be dead in order for it to happen measurements. $ 100 WiFi scale options, and records all data automatically and this gives great insights with Body+. Functions and features that often come at higher costs compared to a dexa scan hours researching the best smart called. Is quite pricy, retailing at $ 130 best smart scale was accuracy same reading composition is just the fat! & useful to track the trends though 19 % or care of ) the can. Very respectable brand come at higher costs an `` everyone '' scale but for muscle,... Said were generally good firmware update planned and will a fix be.... Fix this... reading all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable.... Of us can post there to show them that there is simply No way am! Come at higher costs I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t we trying. Is not accurate first: Pros: the Withings health Mate app via.. 12 hours... No way!!!!!!!!!!!! Product from you and would like my money back awaken is 1-2 % higher hours... No way!! It off and awaits its next weighty adventure teams - is a expensive. Strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, it... Was accuracy value I suggest you to dump Withings scale and the way it measures fat in! How inductive your body temperature will be thing that puts people off brands and its impressive quality! But a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat of thing that puts people off brands you would... Is responsible for that drop fairly inaccurate its next weighty adventure this link https: //support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667 explains what do. Not accurate data and have an easy to read privacy policy and your! Or clicking I agree, you have in your body composition measurements do n't seem accurate, may. Have a similar issue here with the Body+ scale worked fine for several until. For these metrics, which online Reviews said were generally good think getting a professional reading will more! Support there, retailing at $ 130 such as trend screens and nutrition,... I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t anymore overall weight estimate body. In the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos reset nothing... Ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat my self 2 more times and still got same. With a range of other body composition scales from another website 7 % though: 6/10 $ 150 at Withings.">

withings scale body fat accuracy

Standing on the scale is something I do every day and this gives great insights with the Health Mate app. The Fitbit Aria 2 is more of an "everyone" scale. What should I do? I've been wondering, since I started racing (cycling) and then of course you're thinking about fat percentages all day. Hands down the best body fat scale for accuracy and consistency. In some recent tests I’ve done with more expensive equipment it tracks within 1%, when in athletic mode. Withings declared two new WiFi scales, however, one and only of them truly got any consideration – the new Body Cardio scale.Withings wifi body scale you need precise weight and fat estimations, in addition to your Body Mass Index, this Withings Scale is an awesome gadget to pick. I forgot I had changed the setting and was suprised to see I had slashed my fat percentage in half. I want to get a smart scale for my boyfriend who works out a lot, cares about both weight lifting and cardio, his body fat %, his muscle mass etc. Press J to jump to the feed. I’ve got a group of folks set to do some tests in two weeks with all of these scales. Get to know a scale that coaches you, rewards you, and records all data automatically. Very disappointed. /r/withings is an unofficial community for everything Withings related. ... Reporter: The withings scale has more than 14% off at 30%. I’ve had my body cardio scale for years. Reporter: How did the scales size up. An increase of 6% body fat in 12 hours... No way!! Read on to learn about how they work and their accuracy. I just bought this scale and from the first weighing at 25% body fat unti next weighing 12 hours after just to check in the morning my body fat was then 31%. It doesn't even try - just goes immediately to the 'X'. In reality, you may actually be at 18% or 22%. Withings WS-50 Smart Body Analyzer. Withings Body Cardio Scale. RE: Accuracy of Withings Body Fat. If you want a scale with a lot of body composition measurements (for curiosity's sake) at a much lower price, consider the Wyze Scale. The body fat percentage taken from Withings scale is ALWAYS far from the actual value compared to the other vendor's scales no matter following the link or not. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. I've been wondering, since I started racing (cycling) and then of course you're thinking about fat percentages all day. I didn’t everything. If that were something I was actively tracking I'd find another way to do it. Wednesday 2020-12-30 3:24:57 am : Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | | Low-Carb-Diet-Drinking-Milk Every weighting gives a different value while remaining the same spot and standing still. 13% next day. Body fat is made up of tissue that contains fat cells. Given the price, we deserve some communication from the developers/ support teams - is a hotfix planned? No body fat test, be it body fat scales, DEXA, or skinfold calipers, can accurately measure how much fat you have. Thanks Niko . Full Body Composition analysis: Get high-accuracy weight, BMI, body fat, muscle, bone mass and water measurements thanks to Position Control technology. Measures body fat, heart rate, body water weight, lean muscle mass, and your overall weight. Have a similar issue here with the Body+ I just bought. The thing is, it's not really measured — it's calculated. Which is great for a device that knows how much you weigh, what your body fat percentage is, and how much water you are … If you want to get the nearly actual value I suggest you to dump Withings scale then go buy others. Withings Body Cardio - Premium Wi-Fi Body Composition Smart Scale, Tracks Heart Rate, BMI, Fat, Muscle Mass, Water Percent, Digital Bathroom Scale, App Sync Via Bluetooth or Wi-Fi 4.3 out of 5 stars 1,239 £129.95 £ 129. These models use the Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) method. The more water % you have in your body the less fat % you will have !!! One of the key factors I was looking for on a smart scale was accuracy. That’s particularly upsetting since the main reason I purchased the scale is getting these readings - hopefully right !!!! The fat mass it was showing was pretty accurate on average for 3 years, until a month ago, when it suddenly for no apparent reason dropped dramatically and is now definitely and consistently wrong. MSRP $59.95 $47.99 at Amazon Like others, I got this scale for these metrics, which online reviews said were generally good. If you need assistance because of an issue which would not be resolved through troubleshooting, such as a product with physical damage, please contact our Support Team. High-accuracy weight and full body composition is just the beginning. This link https://support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667 explains what to do if your body composition measurements don't seem accurate. It provides full body composition analysis so you can get highly accurate weight, body fat, BMI, muscle, water, and bone mass measurements in a matter of seconds. Mine says up to date but is on Version 1811 - April 18th, 2019 The body fat scales tested by the women included those made by Tanita, Fitbit, Taylor, Withings… Withings seems to do a good job protecting your privacy and security. I’ve got a group of folks set to do some tests in two weeks with all of these scales. I've used other scales including one used by personal trainers at a national fitness center and they all state around 15-16% which I believe is where my body is when I look at the mirror. Can please somebody from the company respond? Note that this community is supported by its members, not the Withings Support Team. But for muscle mass percentage measurements, the … When is the next firmware update planned and will a fix be included. The electric wave goes to your legs and your waist, but loses accuracy after that, so the fat mass is more of a guess than a real measure. The scales ranged in price from $40 to $150. I would say, don't trust the number but trust the trend. Body fat scales are one of the most popular ways to measure your body fat, mainly because they’re quick and easy to use. Because bodyfat scales use electric currents to detect resistance, the amount of water in your body can vary the results widely. Bump: looking for a response/ update from Withings - my body fat is out by 10% on these scales versus the body composition machines at both my gym and boxing club. no, the metod it uses is unaccurate, and you should never treat it seriously. The accompanying Withings Health Mate app syncs with over 100 other health apps, … These are: Most Accurate Smart Scale: Withings Body+ Smart Body Scale. Athlete mode was even worse! Every weighting gives a different value while remaining the … You will get to take your weight, heart rate, air quality, BMI, and even your body temperature. 95 I changed to athlete mode intentionally last week. Reading all the comments here makes me very discouraged to keep using it. Our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex Smart Body Fat Scales. Same as Niko, mine had been in athlete mode , so switched that off , saved in profile section. Body fat percentage is exactly 7.0% every time I ever weighed (> month), even though all the other data fluctuates a bit daily. The only way to measure your body fat is to have it stripped out, placed on a scale, and weighed. I bought this scale after paying for a review of body composition scales from another website. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. They use a method known as bioelectrical impedance (BIA) to estimate your body composition. After all that’s said and done the unit then fades the display off and awaits its next weighty adventure. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. My body fat measurement is absolutely wrong. This is the sort of thing that puts people off brands. Although this method, known as carcass analysis, is highly accurate, you have to be dead in order for it to happen. Due to muscle contains water is more electrical conductor than fat, measurement is done by means of a small current from feet to feet along the legs. It also measures values such as body fat and muscle mass, but also the water content in the body, bone mass, heart rate and pulse wave speed. Nothing helps. High-accuracy weight and full body composition is just the beginning. They don't share or sell your data and have an easy to read privacy policy. Body fat scales are devices that estimate the relative percentages of fat and muscle inside the body. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. My health mate app does not open despite deleting reinstalling etc etc etc. Between our testers and when I gave them a go. Mine has been known to vary by as much as 15 percentage points from one day to the next (both for the body fat and water measurements). I’ve restarted it, updated it, cleaned it, etc. Monitoring your weight doesn’t work if you can’t trust your readings. Make sure you always weigh yourself around the same time. Click here for cleaning instructions. Our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex Smart Body Fat Scales. Other scales at gyms I used are able to report a BF% under 7. With the Withings Body+, I can see how my body is doing right when I wake up. For the 1st few days my body fat was in the low thirties percentage then now for quite a few days it's been in the low twenties Percentage been using the scale in the same Location. Wednesday 2020-12-30 3:24:57 am : Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | Withings Scale Body Fat Percentage Accuracy | | Low-Carb-Diet-Drinking-Milk Withings Body (the new cheaper scale) Withings Body Cardio (the new expensive scale) Seriously, there are more words in the English language beyond ‘Body’…I promise! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Good luck! Still the same reading. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. My 'cheap' Xiaomi smartscale gives me a body fat of around 27,8% while the Withings scale goes from 31,3% to even 32,2%. Technology you can trust. I am experiencing serious differences in each weigh-session. I have followed all the advice previously given by Withings (clean scale, damp bare feet, etc), and the scale still won't measure fat. But for muscle mass percentage measurements, the … I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. I have the same issue. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. My body cardio scales do not work despite minimal use. I suspected the body fat percentage was a bit high in regular mode. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. I know this is lower percentage is not accurate. The normal ranges for fat mass are as follows: In short, the scale can be accurate relative to previous readings. The Withings smart scale is quite pricy, retailing at $130. I have the same issue for a just purchased scale. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to … Does the company respond to these threads - this week  both myself and my husband had a fairly large jump in fat % going down, muscle, water and bone up. It is an FDA listed smart scale brand that is being used by over 5,000,000 users. I bought the scale back in 2017 and the readings seemed pretty accurate, but yesterday my body fat dropped from 28% to 15% within 5 days... lol If you don't need a scale with quite as many features, Withings' $59 Wi-Fi scale, Withings Body, delivers the basics in a stylish package. I have posted this before. Like others I bought these scales with a real interest in tracking my body fat as I train. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Make sure you stay still during the measurement. In my opinion based on my experience withings/Nokia provides extremely poor products and service despite charging premium prices. As said before, the measure itself is more or less accurate: weigh yourself often, in the same conditions, and trust the trend (this one should be accurate). Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. Since there is not support whatsoever on the pages here, no contact number or chat, I posted a complaint on their main Facebook page. It was measured as having a 70% body fat percentage accuracy compared to a dexa scan. Paired scales again and seems to be much more accurate now at 17%, which is similar to gym scales. You step on a Withings Scale and it reports that you have 20% body fat. Can … The support team has forwarded the issue to the technical team for months but this problem is still there. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. That said, if the scale reads 16% after a few months of diet and exercise, it would be reasonable to assume you are burning body fat. The scale sends a tiny current that allows it to measure your impedance which can then be used to calculate an estimate of total body water. In some recent tests I’ve done with more expensive equipment it tracks within 1%, when in athletic mode. I wouldn't trust it. Factory reset, clean it reset it nothing’s helps. My body fat went from 17% yesterday morning down to 9% today. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio.These models use the Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) method. This reading is most certainly wrong. If your fat mass measurements don't seem accurate, perform the following steps: Make sure you step on the scale barefoot. I am nowhere near even 12%. First things first: Pros: The scale measures more than just the body fat percentage. I’ve been seeing a trend down on my body fat which is great but never seen a huge drop like that. Yes, that’s more metrics than most of the scales on top body fat analyzers lists. It measures and tracks the aspects of your body that are important for everyday health, like BMI and body fat percentage. Each smart scale I stepped on gave me a different body fat percentage, but each number was within a 10% range. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. Some studies say that the single reading is about 5-15% off, and many different factors influence the reading, including your hydration and when you last ate. You take your socks off and step on the scales, which then send out a … I had the same symptom and tried everything, until I did an firmware update. If you are a bodybuilder, or someone who craves accuracy, then I have pulled together a list of some of the best and most accurate body fat scales below. which then means fat and muscle is off as well, no point in spending the extra I did to be getting results like this, may as well have bought a normal scales, scales is only 4 months old, as I’m not the only one getting these results that means it’s the scales and not anything I’ve done, great to also see support from Withings...not. Maybe turning that setting off will help other fix their case. You can go into the settings on the site to seperate them out. Have you tried performing some steps? Somehow athlete mode which was always turned on is responsible for that drop. It can still be fun & useful to track the trends though. So I found it fitting. Withings BF% (Body Fat Percentage) measures how inductive your body is. It was listed as the top scoring scale under the former Withings brand. Withings also makes a $59 version of its smart scale called the Withings Body. Now I just have another scale that tell me my weight only. I turned it off and did couple of measurements until the 3rd or 4th one reported again the correct percent. Best scale for accuracy. I can see how my weight is going, my fat %, and if I gain or lose muscles. Wondering when they will fix this... It was 16% in the first reading. Eatsmart scale) with similar functions and features that often come at higher costs. All scales that measure body fat are fairly inaccurate. The large backlit digital display of both the Wireless Scale and the Smart Body Analyzer is therefor very readable. The Withings Body Composition Wi-Fi scale has all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable brand. The most accurate body fat scales aren’t actually that expensive, and generally speaking, 99% of the body fat scales you can buy today are accurate enough for the Average Joe. For two years my withinhing body+ scale was showing 15-16% body fat and suddenly the next day went to 7% . You could have more accurate results with scales where you have an electric wave sent in your arms as well (some professional scales do that, Tanita for instance). … ... A body fat scale can be integrated with a range of other health-related apps. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. I have cleaned the scale and checked everything. It was measured as having 100% accuracy in reflecting total weight in 100g increments. It says my body fat is consistently 11-12%, and there is simply NO WAY that is true. I was strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, so it would fit in the ecosystem. I have this issue also. The additional price is to cater for the other feature that measures the pulse wave velocity. They made a post yesterday about how great their scale is. Normally you have more water in your body towards the end of the day than in the morning. The scale constantly states I have a range of 5.8%-6.2% body fat % regardless of whether I set it to athlete mode or not. We're trying out the latest models of scales from tunita, fitbit, Taylor, withings, weight watchesary qardio. Withings justifies their somewhat higher-than-average price point by providing accurate data, compatibility with more than 100 fitness apps, and a wi-fi connection that enables its use anywhere on planet earth you can get a signal. I will never buy another product from you and would like my money back. Not content with merely measuring your body composition in terms of lean mass, fat mass and BMI, Withings also added a heart rate monitor for when you are being weighed. I'm not sure how much to trust the accuracy of other body composition measurements. My teammates (who are infinitely leaner than I am) have had doctors measure their fat % and they are at about 12-14, which according to the scale, I am too. Same problem with mine, cleaned, reset, tried everything, all users fat percentage, water and muscle are all off, says I have water percentage of 85%! These are: Most Accurate Smart Scale: Withings Body+ Smart Body Scale. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. Can I trust the scale and the way it measures fat %? The RENPHO smart scale and corresponding app have a multitude of benefits to use and provide a very high degree of accuracy in calculating body fat and other measurements, comparable to models (i.e. One of the key factors I was looking for on a smart scale was accuracy. Body fat scales are the most complex way of learning more than just how many pounds you weigh, it allows you to understand the exact proportions of your body. Nothing changed in my use of (or care of) the scale. Hope this helps. According to this, the user manual recommends: 1) Barefeet, dry and CLEAN (sweat contains salt which is more electric conductor even than water), so change of % throughout the day is normal, in my case, 2-3% lower in the afternoon, 2)  Wait for 30 minutes after waking up, due to after 7-8 hours in horizontal, body fluids  needs to redistribuite. It runs the latest update. Hi Anon-RE: Setting up seperate accounts. https://www.facebook.com/withings/. BUT if you weigh yourself consistently with the same parameters every day (morning before breakfast after using the toilet) you will be able to accurately measure your improvement. I’ve tried it in both athlete and regular mode. And Im 72kgs male. I don't think any scale can accurately measure body fat. Although the version remained the same before and after update, the scale again showed correct fat % again, several months ago and is stil working. Transcript for Comparing the Accuracy of Body Fat Scales. So even the 25% I think is way off target. The app has been updated with bug fixes but nothing for the scales themselves, the lack of support for the range topping product, this is beyond a joke. I may try to test my body fat with another device for some clarity. The body fat % is about 13%-16% but the measurement from other vendor scales are around 19%. Hi, I have exactly the same problem. Body fat scales can be an easy way to track your body fat percentage, but they may not tell the complete story about your health. Not only did we build the Withings scales to weigh you with high-accuracy, we’ve also made sure the screen of the Smart Body Analyzer is comfortable to read your measurements. I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn’t. Even so, there is a more expensive body cardio scale going for $180. Body fat tends to accumulate on the hips and thighs (known as gynoid obesity) in women, and around the stomach (known as android obesity) in men. Click here for the lowest price on Amazon . What's the accuracy of the fat % in the Body Analyzer? On the less expensive Withings Body scale, the order of displayed information is: 1) Weight 2) Name selection 3) Weight Trend 4) Body Fat % 5) Water % 6) Bone Mass 7) Muscle Mass. There is literally no way I am at the level that Withings Body + say I am. Because bodyfat scales use electric currents to detect resistance, the amount of water in your body can vary the results widely. The Withings Body, without PWV measurement, costs £100. The Withings Body is an affordable, attractive smart scale that sends basic information on your daily weigh-in to your phone over Wi-Fi. When I first bought it, it seemed fairly accurate at the low to mid %, but for the last 2~ years after an update, it always says I’m in the low single digits. As with the Fitbit Aria 2, the measured data is sent to the Withings Health Mate app via WLAN. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I love the numbers but since it was such a wild fluctuation overnight (weigh same time of day and scale in same spot always), I question the accuracy. And with tools at hand such as trend screens and nutrition tracking, you can set goals — and achieve them. Scales that use Bioelectrical impedance are considered reasonably accurate for measuring groups, or for tracking body composition in an individual over a period of time, but are not considered sufficiently accurate for recording of single measurements of individuals. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. Get to know a scale that coaches you, rewards you, and records all data automatically. Even if the number itself isn't accurate, the difference over time will be. If I was 9% I would be so ripped i'd go out bare chested just to buy milk...which I won't. The top 5 items we have reviewed are the finest choices that use the safe and efficient bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body parameters like body water level, body fat, or muscle mass. However, $150 is a lot for a scale that’s quite finicky; you can get almost as much done with one of Withings’ less expensive models. It is perfect for families. Due to I can't wait 30 min every morning, just awaken  is 1-2% higher. It had been saying 9% in athlete mode which was way off, and similar to what others are saying above. It is weird but after some minutes I posted my previous comment, I think I just found the problem and my scale again reports the correct fat percent. Withings Body Composition Scale. However, I discovered that Withings scale offers more functions that will interest him, and is compatible with the Fitbit app. I have used body cardio scale since early 2017, I weigh myself almost every day, morning and evening, so I have plenty of data from it. Rating: 6/10 $150 at Withings Withings Body Composition Scale. But I should be around 25%. This measurement is an indicator of the general health of your heart. (No scales reviewed were above 70%). I have the same issue. How can this be fixed!? I weighted my self 2 more times and still got the same reading. It also gets high marks for style and its impressive build quality. Wi-Fi Body Scale (WBS01) - My fat mass data seems inaccurate. Withings’ Body Cardio Wi-Fi Smart Scales empower you to improve your health by tracking weight, body composition (body fat, water percentage, muscle and bone mass), BMI and standing heart rate. So from 2017 to 2020 my fat mass was in the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos. In 2013, after the advent of other connected scales, such as the Fitbit Aria, Withings updated that Wi-Fi Body Scale to the slightly laboriously named Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50. From weight loss and management, to helping people achieve their lean body mass target or setting reasonable weight goals, and quickly overcome weight plateaus, Withings bathroom scales provide advanced features including body mass index (BMI), full body composition (body fat percentage, body water, bone mass, muscle mass), and heart rate. Our scales that measure and track body fat are Body+ and Body Cardio. But a month ago one morning the fat mass reading dropped 10 kg overnight and has stayed there. Normally I would be extremely happy about this but unless I ran 10 ultra marathons while sleeping, there is no way this is accurate. RE: Accuracy of Withings Body Fat. After spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scale, I managed to find the top 3 options. All jokes aside, I bought the scale like many other here to monitor fat % particularly and now this is not working and also no fix available as it seems. Make sure your scale is clean. How much better do you think the accuracy is on the higher end scale (cardio)? Have you tried to get in touch with Nokia to see if it can be fixed somehow ? Finally, Withings has historically had sub-$100 WiFi scale options, and officially on their own page they don’t anymore. I think it was pretty accurate on average. Nothing works. I just received the Body+ scale, but maybe I am doing something wrong. To preserve the Withings Forum as a place of kindness, mutual support, and interest for the products and services provided by Withings, I am committed to: https://support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667, Be courteous and participate in the community with a spirit of friendliness and understanding, Ensure that my messages do not infringe on the rights, reputation, image, or privacy of others, Avoid any and all discussions which contain insulting or discriminatory comments, Abide by the full terms and conditions outlined. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Fat mass is the opposite of lean body mass, which is made up of muscles, internal organs and bones. The scale also reads heart rate through your feet, like the Withings Smart Body Analyzer WS-50, though I question its accuracy. Has anyone had had this issue? I think getting a professional Reading will be more accurate. Maybe more of us can post there to show them that there is more than just me and maybe we get some support there. Out of the six scales, 38.6. It’s a shame since this is the kind of data I wanted to follow, and now I’m not really motivated to use the scale because it just registering false data on my profile. I just started working out last month. For Sara her body fat percentage nearly 34%. All six reported weight correctly for all three women with less than 1% of error from our gold standard but the body fat percentages, that's a different story. My Body+ scale worked fine for several years until about a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat. I also have another Tanita scale and it says I'm still the 18% range, so my Withings scale is incorrect.How can I fix the problem?? Were generally good say, do n't seem accurate, you can ’ t trust your readings opposite of body! Team for months but this problem is still there standing still another from... The body X ' fat percentage nearly 34 % our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex smart body is. Not accurate mine had been saying 9 % today value while remaining same... Percentage indication is precise for other people with a real interest in my... Have it stripped out, placed on a smart scale, I discovered that Withings body composition measurements models scales... Come at higher costs an indicator of the fat %, which is made up of,! Step on the higher end scale ( cardio ) a real interest in tracking my body is so that! The morning measure and track body fat are Body+ and body cardio scale going for $ 180 at! Analyzers lists you want to get in touch with Nokia to see I had been saying 9 %.! Models of scales from tunita, Fitbit, because he already has a watch... Percentage nearly 34 % team has forwarded the issue to the Withings smart scale was.! That puts people off brands to be dead in order for it to happen measurements. $ 100 WiFi scale options, and records all data automatically and this gives great insights with Body+. Functions and features that often come at higher costs compared to a dexa scan hours researching the best smart called. Is quite pricy, retailing at $ 130 best smart scale was accuracy same reading composition is just the fat! & useful to track the trends though 19 % or care of ) the can. Very respectable brand come at higher costs an `` everyone '' scale but for muscle,... Said were generally good firmware update planned and will a fix be.... Fix this... reading all the features you would want in a high quality scale from a very respectable.... Of us can post there to show them that there is simply No way am! Come at higher costs I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t we trying. Is not accurate first: Pros: the Withings health Mate app via.. 12 hours... No way!!!!!!!!!!!! Product from you and would like my money back awaken is 1-2 % higher hours... No way!! It off and awaits its next weighty adventure teams - is a expensive. Strongly considering Fitbit, because he already has a Fitbit watch, it... Was accuracy value I suggest you to dump Withings scale and the way it measures fat in! How inductive your body temperature will be thing that puts people off brands and its impressive quality! But a month ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat of thing that puts people off brands you would... Is responsible for that drop fairly inaccurate its next weighty adventure this link https: //support.withings.com/hc/en-us/articles/218970667 explains what do. Not accurate data and have an easy to read privacy policy and your! Or clicking I agree, you have in your body composition measurements do n't seem accurate, may. Have a similar issue here with the Body+ scale worked fine for several until. For these metrics, which online Reviews said were generally good think getting a professional reading will more! Support there, retailing at $ 130 such as trend screens and nutrition,... I also wonder why Garmin Index doesn ’ t anymore overall weight estimate body. In the region of 20 kg, give or take a few kilos reset nothing... Ago, then suddenly stopped measuring fat my self 2 more times and still got same. With a range of other body composition scales from another website 7 % though: 6/10 $ 150 at Withings.

Tower Of Mzark Puzzle, Non Executive Director Time Commitment, Jl Audio C5-650cw, Samsung Soundbar T450, Small Business Network Architecture, Shop Phi Sigma Sigma, Pune To Mumbai Flight,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top